📍 Serving All of Utah

WE BUY YOUR
CARD COLLECTIONS

Selling your Magic: The Gathering or Pokémon cards? Singles, bulk, or sealed product — get a fair cash offer with no lowballs, no hassle, and local pickup available.

Process

THREE SIMPLE STEPS

No guessing games. Send us what you've got, and we'll give you a straight answer.

01

Send Us Photos

Snap some pictures of your cards or sealed product and fill out the form below. Bulk lots, binders, singles, unopened boxes — all welcome.

02

Get Your Quote

We'll review everything and send you a fair market offer within 24 hours. No obligation, no pressure.

03

Get Paid

Accept the offer and get cash — in person if you're local, or we'll arrange shipping and pay via your preferred method.

Collections

WHAT WE'RE BUYING

We're interested in everything from bulk commons to high-end singles to unopened sealed product. Here's what we look for.

Magic: The Gathering

  • Complete or partial collections
  • Commander decks & staples
  • Modern, Legacy & Vintage singles
  • Bulk rares, mythics, and foils
  • Old school / Reserved List cards

Pokémon TCG

  • Vintage WOTC era cards (Base Set, Jungle, Fossil)
  • Modern chase cards & alt arts
  • Graded slabs (PSA, CGC, BGS)
  • Complete or partial sets
  • Bulk holos and reverse holos

Sealed Product

  • Booster boxes (MTG & Pokémon)
  • Elite Trainer Boxes (ETBs)
  • Bundles, fat packs & collection boxes
  • Blister packs & promo boxes
  • Vintage sealed (WOTC, old sets)
  • Pre-release kits & special editions
Why Carter's

FAIR DEALS, REAL PERSON

No corporate buylist algorithms. Just a fellow collector who knows the market and pays accordingly.

💰

Competitive Offers

Prices based on current market data, not lowball buylist rates.

Fast Turnaround

Most quotes returned within 24 hours. No waiting around for weeks.

🤝

Local Pickup

Based in Utah — we can meet up locally so you don't have to ship a thing.

📦

Ship-In Friendly

Not local? No problem. We'll walk you through safe shipping and cover costs on large lots.

FAQ

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Everything you need to know about selling your cards to us.

How do I sell my Magic: The Gathering cards in Utah?

Just send us photos of your collection through the quote form on this page. We'll review your cards and send you a fair market offer within 24 hours. If you're in the Salt Lake City area, we offer free local pickup — no shipping needed.

What Pokémon cards do you buy?

We buy all Pokémon cards including vintage WOTC era (Base Set, Jungle, Fossil, Team Rocket), modern chase cards and alt arts, graded slabs from PSA, CGC, and BGS, sealed product like ETBs and booster boxes, complete or partial sets, and bulk holos. If it's Pokémon, we're interested.

Do you buy sealed product?

Yes — we buy all sealed product for both Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon. That includes booster boxes, Elite Trainer Boxes, bundles, blister packs, collection boxes, pre-release kits, and vintage sealed from older sets. If it's factory sealed, we want to see it.

Do I have to be in Utah to sell cards to you?

Nope. While we offer free local meetups around Salt Lake City, Provo, Ogden, and the Wasatch Front, we also accept shipped collections from anywhere. We'll walk you through safe shipping and cover shipping costs on large lots.

How fast will I get a quote?

Most quotes are returned within 24 hours of submitting photos. There's no obligation to accept, and we're happy to answer questions about how we priced things.

How do you determine your offer prices?

We use current market data from TCGPlayer, eBay sold listings, and other real-time pricing tools. You'll get a competitive offer based on what cards are actually selling for — not an outdated buylist.

Do you buy bulk or just expensive cards?

Both. We buy everything from high-end singles and Reserved List staples to bulk commons, uncommons, and energy. If you've got boxes of cards sitting in a closet, we want to hear from you.

READY TO SELL?

Fill out the form and we'll get back to you within 24 hours with a quote. You can also reach out directly — whatever's easiest for you.

carter@carterscardshop.com
📍 Salt Lake City, Utah

REQUEST A QUOTE